Jersey Flegg Cup records are from 2018–present
| ASHFORD, TJ | Warriors 2025–26 |
| BALLIN, Matt | Manly 2019 |
| BARNES, Anthony | Sydney 2018–22 |
| BARNES, Ash | Canberra 2019–20, 2023 |
| BETTRIDGE, Adam | Newcastle 2020 |
| BOULOUS, Greg | Warriors 2019 |
| BRENNAN, Craig | Parramatta 2023 |
| COLLINS, Wayne | St George Illawarra 2018 |
| CROTTY, Chris | Manly 2026 |
| DALLALANA, Andrew | Cronulla 2021, 2023–26 |
| DOBSON, Michael | Newcastle 2024 |
| DUREAU, Scott | Newcastle 2019 |
| DUVE, Timoci | Kaiviti Silktails 2024–26 |
| FEENEY, Dean | Parramatta 2018–21; Sydney 2023, 2025–26 |
| GITEAU, Justin | Canberra 2022 |
| GLEESON, Tony | Newcastle 2022–23 |
| GORRELL, Aaron | St George Illawarra 2026 |
| HARDEN, Ben | Penrith 2018–19, 2021 |
| HENDERSON, Brad | Canterbury 2018 |
| HENRY, Ricky | Warriors 2018 |
| HERTSCH, Aaron | St George Illawarra 2023–24 |
| HOLDSWORTH, Daniel | Cronulla 2019–21 |
| HOWLETT, David | Cronulla 2018 |
| JACK, Ben | Victoria 2019–21 |
| JACKSON, Josh | Canterbury 2024–26 |
| KENNA, Scott | Wests Tigers 2022–23; Manly 2024; South Sydney 2025–26 |
| LAMBKIN, Wayne | Manly 2018; Wests Tigers 2019–21 |
| LATULIPE, Leon | South Sydney 2022; Manly 2023; Wests Tigers 2024–25 |
| LEYSHON, Willie | North Sydney 2018 |
| LOWRIE, Todd | Newcastle 2018 |
| MACEY, Jordan | Canberra 2024–26 |
| MARRAPODI, Peter | Mounties 2018 |
| McEWEN, Adam | Manly 2022–23 |
| MILLARD, Shane | St George Illawarra 2025 |
| MISSIO, Guy | Penrith 2020 |
| MOORE, Alex | Newcastle 2025–26 |
| MURPHY, Dan | Melbourne 2026 |
| NAIQAMA, Wes | Kaiviti Silktails 2024 |
| NDAIRA, George | Cronulla 2022 |
| O’CALLAGHAN, Joe | South Sydney 2020–21 |
| O’CONNELL, Chris | South Sydney 2023–24 |
| OTT, Trevor | Manly 2020–21 |
| PALMER, Peter | North Sydney 2019 |
| PENNA, David | Canterbury 2019 |
| POCKLINGTON, Grant | Warriors 2025 |
| POU, Paul | Warriors 2024 |
| RANKIN, Jordan | Parramatta 2024–26 |
| ROGERS, Ben | South Sydney 2019 |
| ROLFE, Jono | Penrith 2022–25 |
| RUSSELL, Mark | Melbourne 2023–25 |
| STRINGER, Paul | North Sydney 2020 |
| SULTANA, Shane | Manly 2019; Wests Tigers 2025–26 |
| SWANN, David | Sydney 2024 |
| TALAU, Willie | St George Illawarra 2019–22 |
| THOMPSON, Scott | Penrith 2026 |
| VELLA, Luke | Canterbury 2020–23 |
| WATMOUGH, Anthony | Manly 2025 |
| WILSON, Craig | Wests Tigers 2018 |
| WOOLFORD, Simon | Parramatta 2022 |
| WOOLNOUGH, Adam | Victoria 2022 |
18TH MAN 